Advertisement
Urban Arts Competition 2013 Results
#3
Posted 24 June 2013 - 11:18 PM
Glad to see it done.Thanks to Laser for doing this.
Who were the judges and based on what criteria were the winners chosen?
I'm a bit surprised, me and all the people I talked to about it, all had the same favourite, independently of each other. Now that video isn't even in the top 3 :o
Who were the judges and based on what criteria were the winners chosen?
I'm a bit surprised, me and all the people I talked to about it, all had the same favourite, independently of each other. Now that video isn't even in the top 3 :o
R.I.P. Brainie *30-December '10 - †25-January '14
#4
Posted 25 June 2013 - 02:09 AM
xesya, on 24 June 2013 - 11:18 PM, said:
Glad to see it done.Thanks to Laser for doing this.
Who were the judges and based on what criteria were the winners chosen?
I'm a bit surprised, me and all the people I talked to about it, all had the same favourite, independently of each other. Now that video isn't even in the top 3 :o
Who were the judges and based on what criteria were the winners chosen?
I'm a bit surprised, me and all the people I talked to about it, all had the same favourite, independently of each other. Now that video isn't even in the top 3 :o
I'm baffled by the results as well. Grading off creativity, flow, synchronicity. Am I missing something?
#5
Posted 25 June 2013 - 08:22 AM
The results are final and the decision of FS. Everyone is allowed to disagree with our choices, however, please keep in mind, that since we are the sponsor of the prize pool, the decision is ours and ours alone.
People who are in anyway negative and not showing congratulations for the lucky winners will be dealt with swiftly and their posts removed. Friendly forum nazi giving you a heads up! Don't let me down!!
Well done guys stunning efforts, they we all ALOT of fun to watch!
People who are in anyway negative and not showing congratulations for the lucky winners will be dealt with swiftly and their posts removed. Friendly forum nazi giving you a heads up! Don't let me down!!
Well done guys stunning efforts, they we all ALOT of fun to watch!
Advertisement
#6
Posted 25 June 2013 - 09:48 AM
Thanks La$er and Frozen Sand ; this contest was a great idea, I was proud to participate and I'm glad to be part of the top 3.
Though, I believe that the concept of a 1 or 2 judges rating is improvable and I hope that a vote will be established for the following editions.
Anyway it was definitely a cool event for the community. Congratulations to the winner and to all the participants for their nice work !
Though, I believe that the concept of a 1 or 2 judges rating is improvable and I hope that a vote will be established for the following editions.
Anyway it was definitely a cool event for the community. Congratulations to the winner and to all the participants for their nice work !
This post has been edited by Waluigi: 25 June 2013 - 12:19 PM
#9
Posted 25 June 2013 - 03:51 PM
RaideR, on 25 June 2013 - 08:22 AM, said:
The results are final and the decision of FS. Everyone is allowed to disagree with our choices, however, please keep in mind, that since we are the sponsor of the prize pool, the decision is ours and ours alone.
People who are in anyway negative and not showing congratulations for the lucky winners will be dealt with swiftly and their posts removed.
People who are in anyway negative and not showing congratulations for the lucky winners will be dealt with swiftly and their posts removed.
Again, big thanks to FS for providing this competition, it's greatly appreciated. Also congratulations to the winners and all participants, no doubt they put a lot of effort and time into this.
I'm fully aware that evaluating art is a very subjective thing, based on the taste of the judging individuals. I'm just surprised that the result doesn't cope with the public opinion.
All I was asking for was:
Who were the judges?
What criteria was crucial in the decision making?
I'm not disrespectful or ungrateful. I know music, religion, politics and art are things you can hardly argue about, that's why every art competition on this planet draws up guidelines for the evaluating process :P
I think this type of competition might get more people interested in playing this game, if it gets promoted properly.
R.I.P. Brainie *30-December '10 - †25-January '14
1 User(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users
Advertisement